Can some housing stocks continue to perform in a slowing market?
The U.S. housing market is sending a bleak message. Pending home sales have fallen to their lowest level since tracking began in 2001, housing starts remain depressed, and builder confidence has dropped to a 14-year low. High mortgage rates, stubborn inflation and disruptions to construction labor are making it increasingly difficult for Americans to buy, build or improve homes.
Yet shares of some companies tied to residential real estate are showing resilience, and the investment case is becoming more interesting precisely because the underlying market is so weak.
For wealth advisors, the disconnect highlights an important distinction: stock prices reflect expectations about future business conditions, not simply the current state of the economy. When pessimism is already embedded in valuations, even a modest improvement in demand can produce meaningful gains. That does not make housing stocks a safe bet. It does, however, create an opportunity to examine whether investors are discounting a prolonged downturn while overlooking the potential for a cyclical recovery.
A Housing Market Stuck in Neutral
The latest data suggest that the housing slowdown is more than a temporary interruption.
September pending home sales came in well below expectations, reaching their lowest level since the National Association of Realtors began tracking the measure in 2001. Housing starts totaled just 1.22 million seasonally adjusted annualized units, among the weakest readings since the pandemic recession. Meanwhile, the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index fell to 29, its lowest level since 2012, as prospective buyer traffic deteriorated alongside builder sentiment.
Mortgage affordability remains a central obstacle. Higher borrowing costs have pushed monthly payments beyond the reach of many prospective buyers, while inflation and elevated gasoline prices are squeezing household budgets. Builders face a separate challenge: construction costs and labor shortages make it harder to deliver homes at prices buyers can afford.
Immigration enforcement has added an underappreciated complication. A September survey by John Burns Research & Consulting found that two-thirds of builders reported labor force disruptions, compared with just 13% a year earlier. For an industry that depends heavily on construction workers, those disruptions can delay projects, raise costs and constrain the supply of completed homes.
Economist David Rosenberg has characterized the contraction as a depression. The language is severe, but it captures the pressure facing businesses throughout the residential real estate ecosystem.
For investors, however, the more important question is how much worse conditions can become relative to what stock prices already anticipate.
Why Bad Housing News May Be Priced In
Equity markets are forward-looking discounting mechanisms. A company can report disappointing sales and still see its shares appreciate if investors had expected something worse. Conversely, an apparently healthy business can suffer a falling stock price when its results fail to meet elevated expectations.
Housing-related equities increasingly reflect this dynamic.
Home Depot, a major retailer of home improvement products, recently reached its lowest enterprise-value-to-sales multiple since 2018, excluding the Covid-era market panic. Lennar, one of the country’s largest homebuilders, has returned to valuation levels associated with the housing bust.
These comparisons do not establish that either stock is cheap in absolute terms. Enterprise value relative to sales does not account fully for differences in profitability, leverage, capital intensity or future cash generation. Nor does a historically depressed valuation guarantee a recovery.
Nevertheless, such pricing can create an asymmetry worth investigating. If business conditions continue to deteriorate, the stocks could fall further. But if demand stabilizes, financing becomes more accessible or investor expectations begin to improve, companies whose valuations already reflect substantial pessimism may respond disproportionately.
That possibility is especially relevant for businesses with operating leverage. When fixed costs represent a substantial portion of expenses, incremental revenue can produce a larger percentage increase in operating profits once sales recover. Homebuilders may benefit as construction volumes improve and land, labor and development costs are spread across more completed homes. Home improvement retailers could gain as homeowners resume renovation projects or move into properties that require furnishing and repairs.
The critical distinction is between a company whose shares are inexpensive because its business is temporarily depressed and one whose earnings power is deteriorating permanently. Advisors should not confuse the two.
The Lock-In Effect Is Suppressing Turnover
One unusual feature of this housing downturn is that relatively healthy household balance sheets are contributing to weak transaction volumes.
During the pandemic, many homeowners secured mortgage rates substantially below current borrowing costs. Goldman Sachs estimates that more than 65% of borrowers have mortgages at least two percentage points cheaper than today’s levels.
For these homeowners, moving can be financially unattractive even when they would prefer a larger house, a different location or a change in lifestyle. Selling an existing property and financing another at a materially higher rate can overwhelm the benefits of relocating.
The result is a market in which potential buyers and sellers remain on the sidelines. Low unemployment and limited mortgage delinquencies also keep distressed properties from entering the market in large numbers.
This matters because housing is not merely a market for shelter. It is a transaction-driven economic ecosystem. A home sale can generate revenue for real estate agents, mortgage lenders, title companies, movers, furniture retailers, appliance manufacturers and contractors.
The National Association of Home Builders estimates that buyers of detached single-family homes spend approximately $8,700 more on furnishings, remodeling, appliances and similar items during the year after closing than people who do not buy a home.
When transactions are postponed, much of that spending is postponed as well.
For companies exposed to housing turnover, the problem is therefore broader than the number of homes sold. It is the missing chain of consumer purchases that normally follows a transaction.
The implication for investors is that a recovery in sales could benefit a wider group of businesses than homebuilders alone. It also means that a stabilization in housing turnover could matter even before new construction experiences a substantial rebound.
A Structural Shortage Beneath the Cyclical Weakness
The longer-term supply picture offers another reason not to extrapolate today’s weakness indefinitely.
Over the past 15 years, housing starts have averaged almost 25% below the average of the preceding 15 years, a period that included a larger U.S. population but ended with the housing bust. Estimates suggest that the cumulative shortfall in single-family homes runs into the low millions of units.
This does not mean every missing home will eventually be built, or that pent-up demand will automatically translate into profitable construction. Household formation, demographic shifts, affordability and geographic preferences all influence where demand emerges. A shortage of homes also does little to help builders if buyers cannot qualify for financing at prevailing prices and rates.
Still, a prolonged period of underbuilding creates a potential foundation for future activity. If borrowing costs ease, incomes rise relative to housing costs or household formation strengthens, demand could return to a market that has not consistently produced enough homes to keep pace with underlying needs.
The supply deficit could then amplify a recovery.
For builders, the opportunity would be increased construction volume. For home improvement companies, it could be a renewed cycle of purchases associated with moving, renovating and upgrading existing properties.
The timing remains uncertain. Structural scarcity is a long-term investment consideration, not a near-term catalyst.
What Could Unlock a Recovery?
Investors do not need to assume an immediate housing boom to develop a constructive thesis. Several incremental changes could improve the outlook.
First, lower mortgage rates would improve purchasing power and potentially encourage some homeowners to give up their unusually cheap existing loans. The effect could be meaningful, although the relationship between mortgage rates and sales is not mechanical. Buyers also consider employment security, home prices, taxes and broader economic confidence.
Second, improved affordability could bring previously sidelined households back into the market. That improvement might come from lower financing costs, slower home-price appreciation, income growth or some combination of the three.
Third, a reduction in construction labor disruptions could ease project delays and cost pressures. Builders that manage labor availability, incentives and inventory effectively may be better positioned than competitors to protect margins through the downturn.
Finally, a recovery in housing transactions could revive spending on home-related goods and services. Home improvement retailers could benefit even if new construction remains subdued, particularly if existing homeowners begin investing in properties they have postponed upgrading.
There is also a counterargument. If mortgage rates remain elevated, labor constraints intensify or the broader economy weakens, low valuations may prove justified. Homebuilders could face further margin compression, while retailers could experience weaker discretionary spending. A housing recovery might also be delayed long enough for investors to lose patience with the trade.
Advisors should therefore focus on identifiable catalysts rather than treating low multiples as a catalyst in themselves.
What Wealth Advisors Should Do Now
For wealth advisors, housing-related stocks are best approached as a selective cyclical opportunity rather than a broad bet on an imminent recovery.
The first step is to distinguish among business models. Homebuilders are exposed to construction costs, land inventories, buyer incentives and mortgage affordability. Home improvement retailers depend more heavily on renovation spending, repair needs, contractor activity and household confidence. Furniture and appliance businesses may be particularly sensitive to transaction volumes and discretionary purchases.
Those differences matter when building a position. A portfolio holding several housing-related companies may appear diversified while remaining exposed to the same underlying risk: a prolonged period of weak household mobility and spending.
Second, evaluate balance sheets and cash generation alongside valuation. Businesses with manageable debt, sufficient liquidity and the ability to sustain operations through a downturn have more flexibility to wait for demand to recover. For builders, inventory quality, land commitments and incentives offered to buyers deserve particular attention. For retailers, comparable-store sales, operating margins and the health of professional customers can help distinguish temporary weakness from a more serious deterioration.
Third, establish a clear investment horizon. A stock may offer attractive long-term potential while remaining vulnerable over the next several quarters. Advisors should avoid presenting the structural housing shortage as evidence that prices must rise soon. Clients need to understand that a valuation opportunity can persist, or become more attractive, before the market recognizes it.
Finally, frame the position within the client’s overall portfolio. Housing equities can provide exposure to a domestic economic recovery, but they are not substitutes for diversified equity holdings, high-quality fixed income or appropriate liquidity reserves. Position sizing should reflect the uncertainty surrounding both the timing and magnitude of a rebound.
The Investment Case Is About Expectations, Not Optimism
The housing market is struggling, and there is little reason to pretend otherwise. Transactions are depressed, construction activity is weak, labor disruptions are increasing and mortgage affordability remains a formidable barrier.
But the same conditions that hurt operating results can eventually create investment opportunities when stock prices fall far enough to reflect them.
The United States has spent years building fewer homes than it historically did, while high borrowing costs have discouraged homeowners from moving and spending. Those forces have suppressed activity across an unusually broad collection of businesses. If even part of that activity returns, the resulting improvement could extend beyond homebuilders to retailers, furnishing companies and other businesses tied to residential turnover.
The strongest investment argument is not that a housing boom is imminent. It is that expectations may already be low enough for a modest recovery to matter.
For advisors, that distinction is essential. The objective is not to call the bottom in housing. It is to identify financially resilient businesses whose current valuations may offer an attractive entry point relative to their normalized earnings potential, while ensuring clients can tolerate the possibility that recovery takes longer than expected.
In a market increasingly captivated by artificial intelligence, data centers and the infrastructure supporting them, residential real estate offers a different proposition: a depressed, economically significant sector with substantial unmet needs and a plausible path toward normalization.
The recovery may not arrive soon. But if housing activity eventually begins to thaw, investors who have examined the businesses beneath the headlines may be better prepared to recognize the opportunity.

